Hartley, Maxwell, & Castellano Attorneys at Law
Let Us Help You. Call Today. 805-232-5808
Let Us Help You. Call Today. 805-232-5808

Judge criticized for creating parental alienation

The state appeals court in Pennsylvania has criticized a family court judge for keeping a child in foster care after it received no explanation from the parents for the child’s broken ribs. According to an article in ABA Journal, the judge took unusual steps in a case where an infant had two broken bones. A subsequent ruling in the state’s appeals court said that the trial judge created a situation where there was “judicially created parental alienation.”

Judge makes matters worse

Whereas the courts generally want to keep families together, this judge decided that foster care was a better option than putting the infant in the care of a grandparent, literally telling the family she was doing this because she was waiting for one of the parents to admit guilt to the abuse. This was said despite the fact that child seemed happiest when it was allowed to see its parents.

In support of a petition by a social worker, the judge also would not allow the mother to have representation from two lawyers at the same time. The bench also would not allow evidence of potential explanation of injuries by an expert witness. The appeals court also criticized the judge because she seemed to have a lack of impartiality and a preconceived notion of the facts and would not hear evidence that would potentially contradict those opinions.

Sometimes help is necessary

The trial judge’s actions would seem to be in opposition to the Child Protective Services Law goal of keeping families together, happy and safe. While a judge is generally the final word in a case, an attorney can be a tremendous aid in helping parents facing custody challenges including a difficult family court judge.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
We Are Here To Help. Contact Us With Your Concerns
Email Us For A Response

Tell Us About Your Issue

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Tell us how we are doing and Review Us

Office Location

Hartley, Maxwell & Castellano - Attorneys at Law
5700 Ralston Street, Suite 210
Ventura, CA 93003

Phone: 805-232-5808
Fax: 805-639-0500
Map & Directions

Hartley, Maxwell, & Castellano Attorneys at Law